If you're building a No Stubs Spent team in MLB The Show 26, the fastest path is pretty clear right now: start with Mini Seasons, lock in the guaranteed free diamonds, then use packs and duplicate pulls to grow your stub balance. After testing the current reward paths, we found that not every free card is equally worth your time. A few are real upgrades. A few are mostly stub value. That difference matters.

• Why Mini Seasons Should Be Your First Grind
• What you get from it
• Best Free Diamonds to Prioritize
• Our real priority order
• Pack Strategy: Keep Some, Sell Some
• The better approach
• Is the New Threads Event Worth It?
• Our honest read
• Best No Stubs Spent Path Right Now
• Recommended route
• FAQ
• What is the best free diamond to get first in MLB The Show 26?
• Is Freddy Peralta worth using?
• Should I sell duplicate diamonds?
• Is Mini Seasons better than the New Threads Event?
• Final Thoughts

↖ Why Mini Seasons Should Be Your First Grind

For most NMS players, Mini Seasons is the best starting point because it gives more than one type of reward at once.

↖ What you get from it

• Guaranteed player rewards
• Standard packs and Ballin packs
• Exchange rewards after championships
• Sellable pulls that can fund collections

That's why this mode works so well early. Even if one reward card is only decent, the total return is still strong.

The practical takeaway: if your roster still feels thin, grind Mini Seasons before forcing online event games.

↖ Best Free Diamonds to Prioritize

After looking at the reward path and lineup value, these are the cards we'd target first.

↖ Our real priority order

1. Brandon Nimmo

2. Freddy Peralta

3. Kyle Tucker

4. Value collections only if cheap to finish

Why Nimmo first? Because he's one of the better examples of a card that is both free and immediately useful. In NMS runs, that's exactly what we want.

↖ Pack Strategy: Keep Some, Sell Some

One of the easiest ways to fall behind in Diamond Dynasty is to keep everything just because it's shiny.

↖ The better approach

We should treat free pack pulls in two ways:

• Keep cards that help the lineup now
• Sell expensive duplicates or non-essential pulls

That's especially true if you pull a high-value live series diamond. In our experience, one duplicate elite pull can fund several upgrades at once, which is usually more valuable than holding it.

This is where a lot of NMS progress really comes from. Not luck alone, but what we do with the luck.

↖ Is the New Threads Event Worth It?

Yes, but only up to a point.

The event has good rewards, and Freddy Peralta is worth grabbing. But the deeper grind, especially if it asks for heavy PXP in a short window, is not equally efficient for every player.

↖ Our honest read

• If you win online consistently, the event is solid value
• If you're average online, focus on the guaranteed rewards
• If you mostly play offline, Mini Seasons is still the safer grind

That's the important distinction. Chase guaranteed value first, then decide if the extra grind is worth it.

↖ Best No Stubs Spent Path Right Now

If we wanted the cleanest route with the least wasted time, this is the order we'd follow:

↖ Recommended route

1. Finish Mini Seasons rewards

2. Open packs and sell duplicate value

3. Claim easy collection rewards if you're close

4. Play the New Threads Event for Freddy Peralta

5. Only grind deeper if the rewards still make sense for your time

This works because it creates a full loop:

• You get free cards
• Those cards improve the lineup
• Packs create stub upside
• Stubs help complete smart collections
• Collections create better long-term starters

That's the kind of progression NMS players need: simple, efficient, repeatable.

↖ FAQ

↖ What is the best free diamond to get first in MLB The Show 26?

Brandon Nimmo is one of the best first targets for No Stubs Spent players because he's accessible, useful right away, and doesn't require an unreasonable grind.

↖ Is Freddy Peralta worth using?

Yes. He's not a must-use ace, but he's definitely good enough to slot into an NMS rotation.

↖ Should I sell duplicate diamonds?

In most cases, yes. Selling expensive duplicates gives you more flexibility to improve multiple spots on the roster.

↖ Is Mini Seasons better than the New Threads Event?

For most players, yes. Mini Seasons is the more stable and efficient grind, especially early.

↖ Final Thoughts

Right now, the smartest NMS strategy in MLB The Show 26 is not complicated: Mini Seasons gives the best overall return, Brandon Nimmo is a top free target, and the event is best used for milestone rewards rather than endless chasing.

The players who build strong No Stubs Spent teams fastest usually do one thing well: they turn free content into a plan, not just a pile of cards.